Lol, Now we know that Jack is way too much of a gentleman to even consider striking a blind Cat, even if he prob does have the reflexes of Master Po of Kwai Chang Kaine. (Kung Fu)
I would totally pick Blind Mew for the win! He's got mysterious powers that let him be at three places at once! Plus, I'm sure his other 4 senses are extremely heightened. Also, didn't we have to rescue One Eyed Jack from being kidnapped?