Doctor Noah is the worst companion for me. His accuracy doesnt do no good and dies quickly beside his heal spell but thats the only good of Noah.

Talkin The Plank on Dec 11, 2012 wrote:

I think Old Scratch will be a lot more useful once they get the proposed change of summoned minions scaling with caster level. That takes Scratch from the bottom of the list to somewhere in the middle at least!

After the second promotion he now summons a skeleton corsair which has more health and does more damage.

I actually LOVE Old Scratch. I put the Mojo Echo's on him as well as increasing the area of his spells. Mojo Echo lets him hit several times in one turn. That's up to 3 times of 100-300 one one of the targets and 100-300 on all of them.

Hands down he's my favorite.

As for least, I don't really have the patience for Bonnie. I've seen her in other parties be awesome, but her super low health and inability to doge makes me feel like I have to babysit her when she steps out on the board.

Logansan on Dec 7, 2012 wrote:

I don't really dislike any of them, but the one at the bottom of my roster is Jane Canary, she just dosn't seem to ever do anything special.

How do you get Jane Canary?

I didn't really like Gerard, my Sloth Guardsman, because he kept missing! I promoted him purposely to give him Second Chance, so I don't have a problem with him anymore . But as of now, I guess my least favorite companion is my Unicorn Duelist, as he has such a low amount of health an dies quite easily.

~Hasty Patrick

for me thunder hoof

My least favorite?? old scratch When I first saw his attacks I thought they were awesome but later on I figured
out he dies alot so I mostly put him back in my crew cause When he comes into battle I am like Oh great.
I know he is only good to use for the skeletal pirate summon because it just makes enemys go after the pirate while letting me run! So thats who is my least favorite companion!. -trevor silentsharp level 23

zenkidkailen on Jan 21, 2013 wrote:

In cool ranch you eventually get the seven back together with you taking Wyatt Chirp's place to break the wild bunch.
Once you beat the wild bunch you get one or more members of the seven joining your crew.
Jane Canary and Wild Bill Peacock join privateers
Buffalo Bill joins Swashbucklers
Bat Masterson joins witchdoctors
Billy the kidd joins Buccaneers
and Duck Holiday joins musketeers
You can of course get any that are for the other classes in the crown shop once you complete the required quest.

Thanks!

Least fav.?
Hes's so lame, i forgot his name,um, it's the monquistian who carrys the cross bow.

To be honest i dont even try to keep him alive he's so worthless.

So... i agree with wiz11110

CaptainAureus on Nov 17, 2012 wrote:

Who is the one companion who you really don't like? I don't really mean looks but just their fighting moves. For me it would have to be Nurse Quinn. Her damage is fair but her accuracy is only about 45 and her dodge is only about 40. Whenever I have her in battle she dies no matter what I do to keep her alive. So anyway,that's the one companion who I dislike most. What about you guys?

~Bloody Wolf Freeman~

I hate Kan Po. I upgraded him twice and he STILL dies every time. I also dont liek milo graytail. he rarely hits. - wicked scarlet, lvl 42 witchdoctor

My Tyson Chicken Boxer makes me so annoyed. His laugh is almost as annoying as his usefulness. I can't stand the thing.

Lucas Walker Sky Commander Musketeer

SpearWizardsOn101 on Jan 27, 2013 wrote:

1. Gaspard. He misses a lot, and almost always gets hit for some reason :/.

2. Subodai, until he gets his Upgrade. Like the second reason above, Gets a lot of hits taken in.

I never knew saying my parents died from the Armada would end up in getting such a bad companion like Gaspard. He's the ONLY one of my companions that I very strongly dislike. I mean, I can put up with the Crazy Monquistador with the Crossbow, since he can help out with Bonnie Anne's strength.

I particularly am at a love/hate position with Nurse Quinn, however she is the only companion that can heal, and I can't do a strong heal since I'm a Swashbuckler. I dislike her because Enemies do seem to target her rather quickly, and her heals aren't very strong, but still work out in case of a near end battle.

There are several companions that can heal. Wing Chun, Kan Po, Bison chief, etc. Gaspard isn't a bad companion at all. Any companion can be marked awful if you can't use them properly. Once Gaspard promotes he becomes very powerful and even more powerful after his second promo quest at level 47. If you train companions useless talents, they will be useless themselves. My Gaspard De Vole is fully promoted and he is a great wall. He takes hits, blocks more than not, and dishes out a lot of damage. He actually criticals pretty often too.

Lucas Walker Sky Commander Musketeer

1. Subodai: So sorry! I know you were my starting companion, but you kinda suck as of right now. From reading everyone's posts you get better when you upgrade, but that depends when I will actually start giving you my precious training tomes. I don't have much to complain about you, you block well, you hit with an OK amount of power, you don't miss much, but when I have companions like Ratbeard and Sarah Steele, I am SO not leveling up you. Sorry?

2. Old Scratch: At first I was like, yay, he hits multiple targets and he can make another skeleton, yay, you rock! Then I realized his companion is at least 4 levels lower then Old Scratch, and my Orchid Chameleon puts better dents on my enemies. However, considering what other people said, your skeleton is going to be the same level and better health and damage then you, I'm not complaining to much.

Ratbeard, Sarah and Bonnie make up for it though. I would rather have Bonnie out in the field shooting long distance then Old Scratch.