The game has so many confusing mechanics like critical rating, higher/lower damage against high/low agility, will and strength and more. Because we pirates do not know how to calculate critical chance and other mechanics with strength, will, and agility, there should be a new tab under the windstones, maps, etc. index that shows how to calculate the strange mechanics of the game, even accuracy and dodge chances even though most pirates know how to calculate those. Maybe on that page there could be an actual calculator that finds out critical rating and more when matched against another enemy with certain stats. A tool like this would be great for PvP.